For seafood enthusiasts, nothing compares to the experience of savoring fresh, high-quality seafood. Citarella, a renowned gourmet market, has been a beacon for seafood lovers, offering an unparalleled selection of the freshest catch available. With a commitment to quality, sustainability, and exceptional service, Citarella has become a go-to destination for those seeking the finest seafood. This guide explores what makes Citarella’s seafood offerings unique and provides tips on how to make the most of your culinary adventures.
A Legacy of Excellence

Founded in 1912, Citarella has a long-standing reputation for providing top-quality seafood. Over the years, the market has grown from a small neighborhood shop to a renowned gourmet destination with locations across New York City, the Hamptons, and beyond. Despite its expansion, Citarella has remained true to its roots, focusing on sourcing the freshest and highest-quality seafood.
Citarella’s founder, Joe Gurrera, is a passionate seafood advocate who has personally cultivated relationships with fishermen and suppliers around the world. This dedication ensures that Citarella offers a diverse and consistently fresh selection of seafood, from local favorites to exotic delicacies.
The Freshest Catch
Citarella’s seafood department is a treasure trove for seafood lovers. Their commitment to freshness and quality is evident in every offering, from pristine fillets to whole fish, shellfish, and more. Whether you’re looking for classic staples like salmon and shrimp or more adventurous options like octopus and sea urchin, Citarella’s selection is sure to inspire your culinary creativity.
Sustainable Sourcing
Citarella is deeply committed to sustainability, ensuring that their seafood is sourced responsibly and ethically. The market works closely with suppliers who prioritize sustainable fishing practices, helping to preserve marine ecosystems and ensure the availability of seafood for future generations. By choosing Citarella, customers can enjoy their favorite seafood dishes while also supporting environmentally conscious practices.
Expert Knowledge and Service
Citarella knowledgeable staff is always ready to assist customers in making informed choices. Whether you need advice on selecting the best fish for a particular recipe or tips on how to prepare and cook your seafood, Citarella’s experts are there to help. Their passion for seafood and commitment to customer service ensures that every visit is a rewarding experience.
Tips for Making the Most of Your Seafood Experience

To fully enjoy the seafood offerings at Citarella , consider the following tips:
- Explore New Varieties: While it’s easy to stick to familiar favorites, Citarella’s diverse selection offers the perfect opportunity to try something new. Consider experimenting with less common seafood options like branzino, monkfish, or scallops to expand your palate.
- Ask for Cooking Tips: Citarella’s staff is a valuable resource for cooking advice. Don’t hesitate to ask for preparation tips or recipe suggestions, whether you’re grilling, baking, or pan-searing your seafood.
- Pair with Complementary Ingredients: Enhance your seafood dishes by pairing them with complementary ingredients. Citarella offers a wide range of specialty foods, including fresh produce, artisanal cheeses, and gourmet sauces, to elevate your culinary creations.
- Consider Sustainability: When selecting seafood, inquire about the sustainability of your choices. Citarella’s commitment to responsible sourcing ensures that you can enjoy your meal with peace of mind.
- Visit Regularly: Citarella’s seafood selection changes regularly based on seasonal availability and market conditions. Regular visits allow you to discover new offerings and take advantage of the freshest catch.
Elevating Your Culinary Creations

Citarella is more than just a seafood market; it’s a destination for culinary inspiration. By providing the freshest, highest-quality seafood and offering expert guidance, Citarella empowers home cooks to create restaurant-quality dishes in their kitchens. Whether you’re planning a special occasion or simply indulging in a weeknight meal, Citarella’s seafood is the perfect foundation for your culinary adventures.
In conclusion, Citarella’s dedication to quality, sustainability, and customer service makes it a standout choice for seafood lovers. With a wide variety of fresh and responsibly sourced options, Citarella offers an unmatched seafood experience that inspires creativity and elevates every meal. For those passionate about seafood, Citarella is a destination worth exploring.